Opinion Article
Reflections on Internal and External Quality Assurance in Higher Education in Mauritius

Shaheen Motala Timol
Head of Academic and Quality Enhancement at Middlesex University Mauritius
Having worked for more than a decade in external quality assurance (EQA) as a regulator in Mauritius, and now leading internal quality assurance (IQA) and enhancement within a university, Middlesex University Mauritius, I have had the unusual opportunity to experience quality assurance from both sides of the table. This journey has shown me that while institutions and quality assurance agencies may sometimes perceive themselves as having different priorities, they ultimately share the same purpose: protecting students, strengthening learning, building trust in higher education and ensuring that higher education contributes meaningfully to social and economic development of the country and its people.
Oftentimes, discussions about quality assurance are framed as a tension between compliance and enhancement. Institutions may view EQA as a process of scrutiny and accountability, while agencies sometimes encounter institutions that approach reviews as exercises meant to tick requirement boxes rather than opportunities for reflection and fulfilment of their mission. In practice, I found that the most effective quality systems emerge when IQA and EQA are viewed as complementary processes that inform and strengthen one another.
During my time as a regulator at the Tertiary Education Commission and later the Higher Education Commission of Mauritius, I was involved in institutional audits, programme accreditation, policy development, and the design of national quality assurance frameworks. Over the years, I came to appreciate that while regulatory effectiveness depends on standards and procedures, institutional capacity, capability and engagement are equally important. The strongest institutions were those that were willing to question themselves, learn from evidence and recommendations, and make improvements proactively.
What I learned from EQA is that it cannot on its own enforce a culture of quality within an institution. External reviews can identify strengths and good practices, highlight risks, and provide independent validation, but the day-to-day responsibility for educational quality remains with institutions themselves. Sustainable improvement occurs when institutions, as an ensemble, develop internal processes that encourage critical self-evaluation and collective ownership of quality. From senior leadership and professional services to academic departments and students, quality requires shared responsibility. It should not rest on a single person or on a quality assurance unit.
When I transitioned to Middlesex University Mauritius as Head of Academic and Quality Enhancement, I was privileged to experience first-hand the operational realities behind quality assurance expectations. Academic staff balance teaching, research, student support, and administration. Leaders must simultaneously respond to institutional priorities, national regulatory requirements, professional body expectations, and, in the case of transnational education, the quality frameworks of partner institutions.
From the institutional perspective, quality assurance goes beyond preparing for accreditation visits or audits. It is about understanding how students experience learning, supporting staff development, using evidence to improve programmes and services, and creating systems that drive continuous improvement. External review is therefore most valuable when it validates and strengthens these ongoing efforts instead of becoming an end in itself.
My regulatory background has also shaped how I view the role of the quality assurance authorities. The most influential moments in my own professional development came through participation in international review panels where expert auditors modelled rigorous yet developmental approaches to evaluation. These instances demonstrated that EQA can also be an educative process. A good review process should challenge institutions while also supporting learning, capacity-building, and improvement.
One key observation I have made since joining an institution concerns the place of students within quality systems. As a regulator, I had noted that although institutions and quality assurance agencies consistently state that students are at the centre of higher education, in practice, they were often peripheral to many quality assurance discussions. Much of the attention is directed towards demonstrating compliance, interpreting standards, producing evidence, and managing regulatory requirements. While these activities are important, they can sometimes overshadow the fundamental question of how students actually engage with their studies. Working at Middlesex University Mauritius, I see every day what it means to place students at the centre of programmes, processes and services. Discussions about curriculum design, assessment, student support, digital learning environments, and quality enhancement are not abstract exercises. They are directly connected to the lived experiences, aspirations, and success of our students.
And today’s students, predominantly from Generation Z, learn, communicate and engage differently from previous generations. Institutions often need to respond quickly to changing learner expectations, new technologies, and emerging modes of study, whereas regulatory frameworks are necessarily more cautious and may evolve over longer cycles. The challenge for both IQA and EQA is to ensure that quality assurance remains responsive to contemporary learners while maintaining the accountability and public trust that regulation is designed to protect.
Equally, regulators can learn from institutional needs and challenges. Working within a UK branch campus in Mauritius has reinforced the importance of context, proportionality and practicality. Requirements that appear straightforward at policy level for the regulatory may often prove more complex in implementation at the institution. The introduction of last-minute requirements or policies can also undermine institutional planning, diverting time, resources and attention from enhancement priorities. Understanding institutional realities helps regulators design frameworks that are both robust, realistic and achievable. Effective EQA therefore requires ongoing dialogue with institutions rather than a one-way process of oversight.
This relationship is particularly important in rapidly evolving higher education systems. Mauritius provides an interesting example. Over the course of my career, I have witnessed the sector evolve from a relatively small system dominated by public institutions to a far more diverse landscape that includes private providers, branch campuses, and a growing range of transnational education partnerships. This diversification has expanded opportunities for institutions and students and supported national development goals, but it has also increased the complexity of assuring quality across institutions with very different missions, capacities, and contexts. In my view, this reinforces the importance of quality assurance frameworks that recognise diversity rather than assume a one-size-fits-all approach. At the same time, institutions also operate within an increasingly competitive regional and global environment, where students have growing access to study destinations, online providers, and transnational programmes delivered across borders. For local institutions, competition is no longer limited to providers within the country but extends to institutions across the region and beyond. In this context, maintaining quality becomes a matter of institutional survival, reputation, and sustainability. Strong IQA, designed around an institution’s purpose and students, provide the foundation for sustainable quality. EQA complements these efforts by providing public confidence and a common benchmark against which quality can be assessed. In doing so, it helps institutions demonstrate their credibility and reputation in an increasingly competitive higher education market while safeguarding the interests of students and society.
To conclude, the future of quality assurance, in my view, lies in strengthening the trust and the connections between IQA and EQA. Ultimately, quality assurance works best when it is shared. The government, regulators, institutional leaders, academics, professional staff, employers and students all have a role to play. Building on the expertise gained as a regulator, I look forward to continuing my journey in IQA and enhancement, where I contribute more directly to meaningful improvements in learning, teaching, and the overall student experience.






